Dang, that's something I would come up with!
Or maybe Kayless.
I... I'm speechless. Ahem!
Morrigan does have a point: Durnkrag's fist would count as an unarmed strike (and, without the Improved Unarmed Strike feat as he is, is most likely non-lethal), and he could have possibly combined that with a Smite Evil attempt (I do not know a game where that was something really flashy/magic-looking), that would definitely knock out Mac's lights. Don't forget, 'Krag's got a Base Attack Bonus of +5, combined with a strength score of 17 (+3 to melee attack & damage rolls), and Smite evil would translate damage-wise to 1d3+3+3 (punch + Str + Smite Evil) = 9 damage, and probably on a critical = 18 non-lethal health points.
You have to think: Maybe everybody's not in top condition (aka: max HPs). That's the best logic I have, folks.
If you don't have the time to read, you don't have the time or the tools to write. - Stephen King
DCI Character Stats Thread